The Young and the Restless may be known for its schemers, but Abby Newman has mostly stayed on the light side. However, that could all change if Melissa Ordway had her way. The actress recently sparked fan buzz by revealing her dream role—and it’s far from Abby’s usual polished persona.
Melissa Ordway Dreams of Playing a Villain
In a candid Q&A session on her Instagram stories, Melissa shared that she’d love to play a villain on the show. When a fan asked which character she’d choose if given the chance, she quickly replied, “Phyllis would be so fun to play,” before adding that no one could play her better than Michelle Stafford. That didn’t stop fans from imagining what a twisted Abby might look like.
Melissa’s comment wasn’t just a fun aside. It opened the door to a fantasy storyline that could shake up The Young and the Restless. Abby has had her fair share of drama and even dipped into mischievous behavior in the past. But a full-blown dark turn? That would be next-level.
Let’s not forget Abby’s fiery rivalry with Phyllis. These two women have battled over The Grand Phoenix and even over Chance Chancellor. Though Phyllis ultimately regained control of the hotel, the tension between them never fully died down. The spark is still there—and it’s dangerous.
When Chance returned to Genoa City in 2019, both Abby and Phyllis were drawn to him. He chose Abby, but not without some serious drama along the way. The competition left a mark, and even after the rivalry cooled off, their occasional barbs in public kept fans entertained.
The Young and the Restless: The Case for a Villainous Abby
Now imagine Abby coming back not to make peace, but to stir up trouble. What if she’s been wronged, manipulated, or betrayed? What if she’s finally done playing nice? Turning Abby into a cunning, sharp-edged villain would add fresh layers to her character—and open up endless story possibilities.
Melissa’s performances have already proven she can handle emotional scenes, romantic arcs, and family drama. A villain arc would give her the chance to explore new territory and show off her range. Fans have already responded with excitement online, saying they’d love to see this version of Abby take over Genoa City.
So far, there’s no official word about this twist becoming reality. But the buzz is undeniable. If the writers ever wanted to shake up the Newman family and spark new rivalries, this would be the way to go. Abby could easily rise as a powerful force—one that no one sees coming. The Young and the Restless thrives on reinvention, and Abby’s villain turn might just be what keeps viewers glued to their screens.
Abby going dark would flip The Young and the Restless on its head. Melissa Ordway is clearly game for it. Will the writers dare to take the leap? Stick with Soap Opera Daily for more exclusive scoops and updates on The Young and the Restless.
